What do I get if the company goes bust?Medium

There is a queue, it is fixed in law and contract long before the trouble starts, and where you stand in it was decided the day you bought.

3 min read · 596 words · Updated

Something specific, and it depends entirely on which piece of paper you hold. A company that fails does not lose value evenly across everybody who financed it. It pays out in a fixed order, and that order was settled the day each instrument was issued — not on the day things went wrong.

The queue

Roughly, and with real variation between jurisdictions:

  1. Costs of the insolvency itself — the administrator, the lawyers. Paid first, out of whatever there is.
  2. Secured lenders. They lent against named assets. If the loan was secured on a building, they have a claim on that building rather than on the general pot.
  3. Preferential claims. Often unpaid wages and certain taxes, depending on the country.
  4. Unsecured lenders. Ordinary corporate bonds, trade creditors, most bank debt without security.
  5. Subordinated debt. Lends the same money, has agreed in writing to be paid after the unsecured lenders.
  6. Hybrids — instruments written to absorb losses before the equity is gone, such as a contingent convertible.
  7. Preference shares, then
  8. Ordinary shareholders, who receive whatever is left. Usually nothing.

This is what "residual claim" means on the common stock page. A share is not a small bond. It is the promise to be paid last.

A worked example

A company owes 60 to a secured lender, 50 to bondholders and 10 to suppliers, and its assets are sold for 80.

  • The secured lender takes 60, in full, because the assets it lent against were enough.
  • 20 is left for 60 of unsecured claims, so each unsecured creditor receives 20 ÷ 60 = one third of what they are owed. A bondholder owed 50 receives about 16.7.
  • Shareholders receive nothing, and there is nothing unusual about that.

The bondholder lost about two thirds. The shareholder lost everything. Both held the same failing company.

Why the order matters more than the size

People compare instruments by how much they might lose. The queue says something sharper: whether the outcome depends on the size of the shortfall at all. A secured lender is often indifferent to a company being slightly bankrupt or catastrophically bankrupt, because the collateral covers either. A shareholder is wiped out identically in both cases.

The interesting zone is the middle. Unsecured lenders are where the recovery actually varies with how bad things were, which is why the price of a bond in trouble moves so much: it is the one layer where the answer is neither "paid" nor "nothing".

What changes the answer

  • Security. A claim on a named asset behaves differently from a claim on the company.
  • Structure. Debt issued by a subsidiary that owns the assets is paid before debt issued by the parent that owns the subsidiary. This is structural subordination, and it is invisible from the name of the borrower.
  • The resolution regime. For banks, the modern rules replace the ordinary queue with a statutory one designed to recapitalise the bank rather than liquidate it. Credit Suisse in March 2023 is the case where a hybrid layer was written down to zero while shareholders still received something — an order that surprised many holders and was, on that instrument's terms, what the documents said.
  • Jurisdiction. The queue is national law. Two identical bonds issued by two subsidiaries in two countries can recover differently.

What to read next

Check yourself

Three questions on this page. Your answers stay in this browser and feed the learning record; one you keep missing comes back in the weak-spot drill.

  1. A company owes 60 to a secured lender, 50 to bondholders and 10 to suppliers. Its assets sell for 80. Roughly what does the bondholder receive?

    Show the answer

    About 16.7. The secured lender takes 60, leaving 20 for 60 of unsecured claims, so each unsecured creditor receives one third: 50 divided by 3 is about 16.7.

  2. In which layer of the queue does the page say recovery varies most with how bad the failure was?

    Show the answer

    Unsecured lenders. Secured lenders are often covered either way and shareholders wiped out either way; unsecured lenders sit in between, where recovery depends on the size of the shortfall.

  3. What is structural subordination?

    Show the answer

    Parent debt ranking behind subsidiary debt. Debt issued by the subsidiary that owns the assets is paid from those assets first, so the parent's lenders wait behind it, which the borrower's name does not reveal.

Information and education only. Every page, figure and calculator on this site exists to explain how financial instruments work. Nothing here is investment, tax or legal advice, a recommendation, or a valuation you can rely on. Full disclaimer